The Broker Times · Data Brief
The First Home Buyer Market Is Splitting in Two
Equifax’s Q3 2026 consumer credit analysis, released 4 November 2026, and what it changes about the clients already on your book.
The headline numbers
−16.6%
Mortgage demand, year on year, Q3 2026
Equifax, Q3 2026
+3.34%
Mortgage hardship accounts, quarter on quarter
Equifax, Q3 2026
+5.8%
Mortgage limit balances behind late delinquencies, year on year
Equifax, Q3 2026
+14.9%
Personal loan limits at risk, year on year
Equifax, Q3 2026
−1.6%
Non-mortgage hardship accounts, quarter on quarter
Equifax, Q3 2026
~95%
LVR at origination implied by a 5% deposit, per Equifax
Equifax, Q3 2026
Two separate divergences — keep them apart
Split by industry of employment
Equifax applies the K-shape to first home buyers who used the Government’s 5% deposit scheme, split by industry of employment.
Resilient: buyers likely in more stable or higher-income professions.
Exposed: buyers in rate- and discretionary-sensitive sectors, who Equifax says are considerably more likely to be in mortgage arrears.
Split by borrowing quartile
Top quartile: +$22,000 added to the average first home buyer enquiry, October 2025 to September 2026.
Bottom quartile: −$15,000 over the same period — a $37,000 spread.
Equifax reports this as a separate divergence. It does not describe the quartile split as the two arms of the K.
Where average first home buyer loan sizes fell hardest
Bar lengths are drawn to the percentage or dollar figures Equifax published and are indicative only. Equifax also named Richmond (Sydney), Brookfield (Brisbane) and Stonnington (Melbourne) as recording significant declines, without publishing figures for them. Granite Belt is the deepest fall outside the capitals; Manly the deepest capital-city fall.
Read the measure correctly. Equifax’s note to editors says its Consumer Market Pulse measures credit applications — a lead indicator — rather than RBA balance data. A falling average enquiry is a signal about what buyers are asking for, not a direct measure of settled loan sizes or of property values.
What RG 273 actually says about a past client
- No standing duty to review. RG 273.118 says the best interests duty “does not require you to conduct a ‘periodic review’, or to provide credit assistance to the consumer in the future”. ASIC adds that reviewing circumstances from time to time is good practice.
- The duty starts when you engage. RG 273.118 continues that if you review, or a past consumer contacts you, “the best interests duty will apply to any credit assistance you provide at that time”.
- Prior dealings do not exempt you. RG 273.117: “It does not matter whether you have provided credit assistance to the consumer before.”
- ‘Stay put’ is a recommendation. RG 273.119 says you must not suggest a consumer remain in a credit contract without considering whether that is in their best interests.
- Write down why. RG 273.165(g) lists the options and ultimate recommendation you gave, and the reasons why, among the records ASIC expects.
The call is optional. The standard, once you make it, is not.
Nothing obliges you to ring every scheme-era first home buyer on your book. But the moment that conversation turns into credit assistance — including advice to do nothing — RG 273 applies to it in full.
The Broker Times · Market Data
First Home Buyers in the Top Borrowing Quartile Added $22,000 to Their Average Enquiry While the Bottom Quartile Lost $15,000
Equifax says the first home buyer market is splitting in two, and that a 5% deposit implies about 95% LVR at origination. RG 273.118 says you owe those clients no periodic review — right up until you start one.
In this article
- What Equifax actually published
- The K sits inside one cohort, not across the market
- The $22,000 / $15,000 split is the number to sit with
- Where the falls are concentrated
- What RG 273 says about the client you wrote two years ago
- “Stay where you are” is credit assistance
- A review sequence that holds up
- What to watch next
Most market data tells you something about the deals you are yet to write. This set tells you something about the ones you already have. Equifax’s Q3 2026 consumer credit analysis describes a first home buyer cohort pulling apart — and brokers with those clients on their books are well placed to see it first.
What Equifax actually published
On 4 November 2026, Equifax released an analysis titled Falling Equity and Rising Arrears: Australia’s Emerging K-Shaped First Home Market, carrying the label “Equifax Consumer Credit Analysis – Q3 2026”. Trade coverage followed in the weeks after, which is how it arrived on most broker desks. It is worth going back to what the release itself says, because the framing matters more than the headline.
The topline is demand. Equifax put overall mortgage demand down 16.6% year on year in Q3 2026, inside a secured credit book down 14.5% and an unsecured book down 7.1%. Within unsecured, buy now pay later fell 40% year on year while credit cards rose 4.0% and personal loans edged up 0.6%.
The second half of the release is about stress, and it does not move in one direction:
- Mortgage hardship accounts rose 3.34% quarter on quarter, with state-level stress most pronounced in Victoria.
- Mortgage limit balances sitting behind late delinquencies rose 5.8% year on year.
- Personal loan limits at risk rose 14.9% year on year.
- Non-mortgage hardship accounts fell 1.6% quarter on quarter, although personal loans maintained what Equifax called a high 1.05% rate.
- Headline arrears, Equifax said, remain stable.
That last point deserves emphasis before anyone builds a client conversation on it. The headline number is not deteriorating. What is moving is the composition underneath it — hardship accounts, and the dollar value of credit sitting behind late payments.
Read the instrument correctly. Equifax’s own note to editors says its Consumer Market Pulse measures credit applications, which it describes as a lead indicator, as distinct from RBA balance data. A falling average enquiry figure tells you what buyers are asking for. It is not a measure of settled loan sizes, and it is not a property valuation.
The K sits inside one cohort, not across the market
The phrase “K-shaped” gets used loosely. Equifax used it narrowly, and the narrowness is the useful part. The release does not describe a K across the housing market. It describes one emerging among first home buyers who took advantage of what it calls the Government’s 5% deposit scheme — and the variable that splits them is industry of employment.
On one arm sit buyers likely employed in more stable or higher-income professions. On the other sit buyers employed in rate-sensitive and discretionary-sensitive sectors. Equifax said the second group is considerably more likely to be in mortgage arrears than those on what it called the resilient road.
“As a cohort, First Home Buyers already exhibit structurally higher arrears rates when compared to the rest of the market.”
Kevin James, Chief Solutions Officer, Equifax Australia
Then comes the sentence brokers should read twice. Equifax noted that because the 5% deposit scheme implies roughly 95% LVR at origination, even modest price falls could push the exposed cohort toward negative equity.
That is a conditional statement, not a finding, and it should be repeated to clients as one. Equifax did not say this cohort is in negative equity. It said the arithmetic of a 95% starting position leaves very little room, and that where prices fall, the room disappears quickly.
Why this lands on brokers specifically. If a cohort is splitting on industry of employment, the people holding the fact-finds that record industry of employment are well placed to see it first. A lender running portfolio-level analytics sees the arrears once they appear. A broker with the original fact-find can see which clients sit in the sectors Equifax identified before that point.
The $22,000 / $15,000 split is the number to sit with
Between October 2025 and September 2026, Equifax found the average first home buyer mortgage enquiry in the top quartile of borrowers rose by about $22,000. Over the same period, the bottom quartile fell by about $15,000.
A single average would have shown almost nothing. Split into quartiles, the same data shows two groups moving in opposite directions by a combined $37,000 in twelve months. One group is still stretching. The other has stopped.
For a broker, that gap is a segmentation instruction. The “first home buyer” label on your CRM is now carrying two different clients with different problems. The top-quartile client is a capacity and structure conversation. The bottom-quartile client is a serviceability and resilience conversation, and may not be a transaction at all this year.
It is also a pipeline warning. If the bottom quartile is asking for $15,000 less than it was a year ago, the volume of enquiry that converts into a written loan at your average loan size is falling faster than the raw enquiry count suggests.
Where the falls are concentrated
Equifax named specific markets where the average first home buyer loan size fell hardest over that October 2025 to September 2026 window.
- Manly, Sydney — down 18.7%, or $249,000 off the average loan, which Equifax described as the deepest capital-city fall.
- Granite Belt, Queensland — down 23.3%, or more than $150,000, the deepest fall outside the capitals.
- Noosa — drops of more than $100,000 in the average first home buyer mortgage, with no percentage published.
- Richmond (Sydney), Brookfield (Brisbane) and Stonnington (Melbourne) — named as recording significant declines, with no figures published alongside them.
“buyers are now borrowing substantially less than they were a year ago in order to buy into these suburbs.”
Kevin James, Chief Solutions Officer, Equifax Australia
Reporting the Equifax analysis on 20 November, The Adviser added detail not contained in the release itself: that 14 of the 25 locations with the highest mortgage arrears rates are regional, with the remaining 11 in the outer suburbs of Sydney, Melbourne, Brisbane, Perth and Adelaide. The same report attributed to Equifax an expectation that mortgage arrears will deteriorate further in the March 2027 quarter, with rising unemployment named as the principal threat to repayment capacity. Those two points appear in that outlet’s reporting rather than in the published Equifax release, and are best treated accordingly.
What RG 273 says about the client you wrote two years ago
Here is where a lot of well-intentioned broker commentary goes wrong. It is tempting to read data like this and conclude that brokers are now obliged to go back through the book. ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 273, Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty, issued June 2020, does not say that.
RG 273.118 states that the duty “does not require you to conduct a ‘periodic review’, or to provide credit assistance to the consumer in the future”. ASIC adds in the same paragraph that it is good practice to review the consumer’s circumstances from time to time — good practice, framed as such, not an obligation.
The same paragraph then does something that is easy to skim past. It continues that if you do review the consumer’s circumstances, or a past consumer contacts you, “the best interests duty will apply to any credit assistance you provide at that time”.
The practical shape of it. The outreach is voluntary. The standard that attaches to it, once it becomes credit assistance, is not. There is no partial version of the duty for a courtesy call that turns into a conversation about the client’s loan.
Two neighbouring paragraphs complete the picture. RG 273.117 states plainly: “It does not matter whether you have provided credit assistance to the consumer before.” Having written the original loan neither exempts you nor lowers the bar on the next conversation. And RG 273.116 confirms the duty “applies any time you provide credit assistance to the consumer”, based on the information available at the time.
“Stay where you are” is credit assistance
The single most useful thing in RG 273 for this particular moment is RG 273.119, which says you must not suggest that a consumer remain in a credit contract without considering whether doing so is in their best interests.
That matters because the honest answer for a stretched 95%-LVR first home buyer is very often “there is nothing better available to you right now”. That answer may well be correct. It is still a recommendation, and RG 273 treats it as one.
ASIC’s guidance on refinancing points the same way. RG 273.58 notes that the expenses incurred when refinancing may exceed the cost savings of a new loan, so recommending a new loan may not be in the consumer’s best interests — and that the consumer may benefit from being made aware of minor cost savings, with an explanation of when savings would exceed refinancing expenses. RG 273.120 adds that for consumers thinking about refinancing, you should consider the costs associated with refinancing.
For a client at a high LVR in a market where Equifax has flagged falling average loan sizes, those costs include a practical one: a valuation that does not come in where the client assumes it will. Raising that possibility before an application is lodged is a different conversation from explaining it afterwards.
And whichever way the recommendation lands, RG 273.165(g) lists among the records ASIC expects “the options and ultimate recommendation you gave and the reasons why”. RG 273.169 notes that taking notes contemporaneously is preferable to drafting them at the end of the process. A file that records a considered decision to leave a loan in place is worth considerably more than one that is simply silent.
A review sequence that holds up
If you choose to work through your scheme-era first home buyer clients — and this is a commercial decision, not a compliance requirement — sequence it so that the compliance obligations switch on at a point you have prepared for.
- Segment before you dial. Pull first home buyer settlements from the scheme period and sort by industry of employment, which is the variable Equifax found splits the cohort. Your fact-finds already hold it.
- Separate the two arms. Clients in rate- and discretionary-sensitive sectors are the group Equifax identified as more likely to be in arrears. Those in stable or higher-income professions are a different conversation entirely.
- Check the LVR arithmetic first. If origination was near 95%, establish what you believe current position looks like before the client asks. Equifax’s point was about how little headroom that start leaves.
- Decide what the call is. A genuine check-in that does not touch product is not credit assistance. The moment it does — including a recommendation to stay put — RG 273 applies in full, per RG 273.118 and RG 273.119.
- Consider foreseeable change, not just today. RG 273.48(d) lists reasonably foreseeable changes to the consumer’s personal circumstances and financial situation among the matters to consider.
- Record the reasoning either way. RG 273.165(g) and RG 273.169 — the options, the recommendation, the reasons, written at the time.
- Know where hardship goes. If a client is in genuine difficulty, hardship arrangements are made with the credit provider, not the broker. Confirm the referral path with your licensee or aggregator before you need it.
One boundary worth stating plainly. Nothing above is a substitute for your own licensee’s process. Aggregators differ on what constitutes credit assistance in a retention call and on how those calls must be recorded. Check yours before you build a campaign around this data.
What to watch next
Equifax tied its own forward view to rates. In the release, Kevin James said that with another rate rise predicted, and as overdue balances creep up, “we expect to see continued credit caution among Australian consumers”. He also characterised current conditions directly: “The highest interest rates in 18 years seem to be having a notable impact on consumers’ appetite for credit.”
For brokers, three things are worth tracking into the new year: whether mortgage hardship accounts keep climbing past the 3.34% quarterly increase; whether the quartile gap in first home buyer enquiry widens beyond the $37,000 spread Equifax recorded; and whether the industry-of-employment split shows up in your own book the way it shows up in Equifax’s data.
The broader point is a structural one. For most of the past decade, the data brokers consumed was about acquisition — where the next deal was coming from. A cohort splitting on employment sector at 95% origination LVR is a different kind of data. It is about retention, service, and the quality of a conversation you are not required to have.
RG 273.118 is unusually clear that you do not have to make that call. It is equally clear about what happens when you do. Brokers who understand both halves of that paragraph are in a position to do the useful thing without walking into the avoidable problem.
Key takeaways
- Equifax’s Q3 2026 analysis, released 4 November 2026, put mortgage demand down 16.6% year on year, mortgage hardship accounts up 3.34% quarter on quarter, and mortgage limit balances behind late delinquencies up 5.8% year on year. Headline arrears, it said, remain stable.
- Between October 2025 and September 2026 the average first home buyer enquiry rose about $22,000 in the top borrowing quartile and fell about $15,000 in the bottom — a $37,000 divergence inside one cohort.
- Equifax described the split as running on industry of employment among buyers who used the Government’s 5% deposit scheme, and noted that because such a deposit implies about 95% LVR at origination, even modest price falls could push the exposed group toward negative equity. That is a conditional statement, not a finding.
- RG 273.118 says the best interests duty does not require a periodic review — but that the duty applies to any credit assistance you provide if you do review, or if a past client contacts you.
- RG 273.119 means a recommendation to stay in the existing loan is still a recommendation, and RG 273.165(g) expects the reasons for it to be on file.
Common questions
No. RG 273.118 states that the best interests duty “does not require you to conduct a ‘periodic review’, or to provide credit assistance to the consumer in the future”. ASIC describes reviewing circumstances from time to time as good practice rather than an obligation.
What changes is the standard that applies once you do engage. The same paragraph says that if you review the consumer’s circumstances, or a past consumer contacts you, the duty applies to any credit assistance you then provide. Confirm your own licensee’s position before building any outreach programme.
No. Equifax said that because the 5% deposit scheme implies roughly 95% LVR at origination, even modest price falls could push the exposed cohort toward negative equity. That is conditional, and it should be repeated to clients as a conditional statement rather than a finding about their position.
It is the change in the average first home buyer mortgage enquiry amount between October 2025 and September 2026, split by borrowing quartile — up about $22,000 in the top quartile, down about $15,000 in the bottom.
Equifax’s note to editors says its Consumer Market Pulse measures credit applications, which it describes as a lead indicator, as distinct from RBA balance data. It is a measure of what buyers are asking for, not of settled loan sizes or property values.
RG 273.119 says you must not suggest that a consumer remain in a credit contract without considering whether that is in their best interests — so ASIC’s guidance treats a recommendation to stay put as a recommendation like any other.
RG 273.165(g) lists the options and ultimate recommendation given, and the reasons why, among the records ASIC expects. Whether a particular conversation amounts to credit assistance in your circumstances is a question for your licensee or compliance adviser.
Manly in Sydney, down 18.7% or $249,000 off the average first home buyer loan, described as the deepest capital-city fall. The Granite Belt in Queensland, down 23.3% or more than $150,000, the deepest outside the capitals. Noosa, with drops of more than $100,000 and no percentage published.
Richmond in Sydney, Brookfield in Brisbane and Stonnington in Melbourne were named as recording significant declines, without published figures.
Breaking news for modern brokers
Market data, lender policy and compliance developments, read through what they actually change on a broker’s desk.
Sources: Equifax Australia, Falling Equity and Rising Arrears: Australia’s Emerging K-Shaped First Home Market (Equifax Consumer Credit Analysis – Q3 2026), 4 November 2026. The Adviser, “Mortgage hardship intensifies as FHBs begin to buckle”, 20 November 2026. ASIC, Regulatory Guide 273: Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty, June 2020.
Interactive · Broker Tool
Scheme-Era First Home Buyer: Review Triage
Four questions about a first home buyer already on your book. The tool returns a suggested review priority and the RG 273 paragraphs that become relevant once the conversation turns into credit assistance. It is a prompt sheet, not a compliance determination.
The outreach is optional. The standard, once you engage, is not.
RG 273.118 says the duty does not require a periodic review — and that it applies to any credit assistance you provide if you do review, or if a past client contacts you.
Disclaimer: This article is for general information and professional development purposes only. It does not constitute legal, compliance, or financial advice. Brokers should consult their aggregator’s compliance team and, where required, seek independent legal advice regarding their obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 and ASIC’s responsible lending guidelines.
