The Broker Times · Compliance Brief

$6.75 Million, More Than 300 Car Loans, and No Credit Licence

Federal Court penalties announced by ASIC on 17 November 2026 — and the review that put broker and dealer distribution under the microscope five months earlier.

The Penalties

Party
Penalty
Keo Automotive Pty Ltd
$3.5m
Diamond Wheels Pty Ltd (Lansvale Motor Group)
$2.5m
Ken Keomanivong (director) — plus a 5-year restraint from credit activities
$750,000
Total ordered
$6.75m

All three parties admitted the contraventions. No broker, aggregator or broker business was a party to this proceeding.

The Scale

300+

Consumer car loans provided between 2018 and 2024

~18,000

Unlawful payments received by Keo Automotive across 119 contracts

~6,000

Unlawful payments received by Diamond Wheels across 205 contracts

Zero

Australian Credit Licences ever held by either company

What the Judge Said

“Communicate to vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance that the regulatory requirements are not optional.”

Justice Lee, on the purpose of the penalties, as reported in ASIC media release 26-284MR, 17 November 2026

The Fee Stack ASIC Found in Car Finance

Lender establishment fee$299 – $995

Typical range across the eight lenders reviewed.

Distributor establishment fee$912 – $2,500

A flat $912 at the low end, up to $2,500 at the high end.

ASIC’s worked example — total fees as a share of the loan~18%

More than $9,000 in fees on a $49,162 loan: over $7,800 to the lender and $1,320 to the broker. One lender charged a third fee on top of the two establishment fees.

How It Got Here

Sep 2024

Proceedings commenced

ASIC takes action against the two companies and the director.

Jun 2026

REP 832 published

ASIC reviews 350,000+ loans across eight car finance providers.

Jun 2026

Liability found

Court finds unlicensed credit activity and unlawful interest.

17 Nov 2026

Penalties ordered

$6.75m total, plus a five-year restraint on the director.

The Finding That Reaches Brokers

What ASIC found

“Shortcomings in some lenders’ oversight of distributors like brokers and car dealers who sell their loans.”

Which direction it runs

The finding is about lenders not monitoring their third-party channels. It is not a finding that brokers did anything wrong.

Why it still lands on you

ASIC says many lenders then strengthened product review triggers and “governance and oversight of high-volume distributors” — a process that looks at broker files.

The Broker Takeaway

A dealership penalty is not a broker penalty, and nothing here suggests otherwise. But the Court addressed “others who facilitate consumer finance,” and ASIC has already told car finance lenders to watch their distributors more closely. If you write motor or asset finance, the practical response is to sight every referral partner’s licence status, document who does what, price your own fee stack against ASIC’s published range, and get your licensee’s written position on whether the best interests duty attaches to that work.

Sources: ASIC media release 26-284MR, “Federal Court orders penalties of $6.75 million for unlicensed car loans and unlawful interest,” 17 November 2026 (judgment reported as [2026] FCA 1734); ASIC media release 26-114MR, 9 June 2026; ASIC media release 26-132MR and REP 832 Lifting the bonnet: ASIC’s review of car loans, released 24 June 2026; ASIC Regulatory Guide 273 Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty.

Compliance

$6.75m in Penalties for Car Loans Written Without a Credit Licence. Justice Lee Addressed “Others Who Facilitate Consumer Finance”

The Broker Times·18 November 2026·9 min read

A Federal Court penalty against two Sydney car dealerships reads like someone else’s problem — until you get to the sentence about who the Court was really talking to.

On 17 November 2026, ASIC announced that the Federal Court had ordered $6.75 million in penalties against two south-west Sydney car dealership companies and their director for unlicensed consumer lending and charging unlawful interest. For most brokers, that reads like a dealer story — someone else’s problem, in someone else’s channel.

One sentence in the judgment makes it worth a second look. Justice Lee said the penalties were intended to “communicate to vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance that the regulatory requirements are not optional.”

“Others who facilitate consumer finance” is a broad phrase, and it arrives in the same year ASIC told the car finance market that lenders are not watching their distributors — brokers included — closely enough. For any broker who has diversified into motor and asset finance, or who takes dealer referrals, the practical question this week is not whether the penalty was deserved. It is what the entity at the other end of your referral actually holds, and how your lenders are about to start checking.

What the Court actually decided

According to ASIC’s media release (26-284MR), the penalties were apportioned as follows:

  • Keo Automotive Pty Ltd — $3.5 million
  • Diamond Wheels Pty Ltd, trading as Lansvale Motor Group — $2.5 million
  • Ken Keomanivong, director of Keo Automotive and former director of Diamond Wheels — $750,000, plus a five-year restraint from involvement in credit activities

All three admitted the contraventions. Mr Keomanivong agreed to his penalty; the two companies contested the penalties ASIC sought. The Court found Mr Keomanivong was involved in the contraventions, played a central role in establishing and operating the lending businesses, and that for at least part of the relevant period he knew his conduct was unlawful.

The scale is in the repayment counts rather than the loan counts. Between 2018 and 2024 the companies provided more than 300 consumer car loans and received thousands of repayments under them. Diamond Wheels was the credit provider under 205 contracts from September 2018 to December 2019, receiving almost 6,000 unlawful payments. Keo Automotive entered 119 contracts from January 2020 to August 2023 and received almost 18,000 unlawful payments, including under many of the Diamond Wheels contracts.

Neither company has ever held an Australian Credit Licence.

ASIC Commissioner Alan Kirkland said consumers “who take out car loans are entitled to the protections provided by Australia’s consumer credit laws.” The proceedings began in September 2024; the Court found the companies had engaged in unlicensed credit activities and charged unlawful interest in June 2026, with penalties handed down this month. The judgment is reported as [2026] FCA 1734.

Worth being precise: the parties before the Court were two dealership companies and a director. No broker, aggregator or broker business was a party to this proceeding, and nothing in ASIC’s release suggests otherwise.

The sentence brokers should read twice

Courts choose their words about deterrence carefully, because deterrence is the point of a civil penalty. Justice Lee could have addressed vehicle dealers alone. The judgment as reported by ASIC addresses “vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance.”

“Communicate to vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance that the regulatory requirements are not optional.”

Justice Lee, on the purpose of the penalties, as reported in ASIC media release 26-284MR, 17 November 2026

That phrasing does not create a new obligation, and it should not be read as a finding about anybody who was not in the courtroom. What it does is signal the audience the Court had in mind — the whole chain that puts a consumer into a car loan, not just the entity whose name is on the contract.

For brokers, the useful translation is narrow and practical: in motor finance, the distance between “I introduced the customer” and “I was facilitating the credit” is shorter than it is in a residential deal, because the vehicle, the sale and the finance are often arranged by the same small group of people in the same afternoon. Where your arrangement sits on that spectrum is a question about your authorisation and your agreements, and it is a question for your licensee rather than for a news article.

The other half of the picture: ASIC has already told lenders to watch their distributors

This penalty did not arrive in isolation. In June 2026 ASIC published REP 832 Lifting the bonnet, a review drawing on data from more than 350,000 loans across eight car finance providers.

Its distribution finding is the one brokers should know. ASIC found “shortcomings in some lenders’ oversight of distributors like brokers and car dealers who sell their loans.”

Read that carefully, because the direction matters. The finding is about lenders failing to monitor their third-party channels. It is not a finding that brokers as a group did anything wrong. But it is the finding most likely to change a broker’s week, because the fix sits on the broker’s side of the relationship.

Commissioner Kirkland’s framing was blunt: “Responsibility for consumer outcomes cannot be outsourced.” He added that “lenders should be monitoring the experiences of borrowers, especially where loans are sold by third parties,” and that the review “lays bare the potential risks when lenders fail to effectively monitor third-party distributors.”

ASIC also reported what the lenders did next. Many strengthened product distribution conditions, product review triggers, and governance and oversight of high-volume distributors. That last phrase is the one to sit with. If you write volume in motor finance, you are a high-volume distributor, and “strengthened governance and oversight” means someone at your lender is now building a process that looks at your files.

Where this lands on a file: the fee stack

REP 832’s cost findings explain why distribution is where ASIC is looking. ASIC found the overall cost of car loans could vary widely, and that total fees could be significant, particularly on lower-value loans.

On the review’s figures, loans typically carried two establishment fees: a lender fee of between $299 and $995, and a distributor fee ranging from a flat $912 up to $2,500. One lender, which charged the highest total fees, imposed a third fee as well. In ASIC’s example, one customer paid more than $9,000 in fees on a $49,162 loan — more than $7,800 of it to the lender and $1,320 to the broker, with total fees around 18 per cent of the loan amount.

Two things follow for brokers, and neither requires any assumption about wrongdoing.

First, a distributor fee that can reach $2,500 on a mid-sized car loan is a number a client will eventually see, compare and ask about. The broker who can explain the fee, what it covers and why the structure was chosen is in a straightforward conversation. The broker who cannot is in a complaint.

Second, when ASIC publishes a fee range for a sector, that range becomes the implicit benchmark against which any individual file is read — by a lender’s distribution review, by a licensee’s audit, and by AFCA. Knowing where your own files sit inside that published range is cheap information that is now worth having.

The duty question nobody has answered cleanly for motor finance

Here is where brokers should be careful with anyone — including other brokers — who speaks with total confidence.

The best interests duty sits in s158LA of the National Credit Act, and ASIC’s guidance on it is RG 273. Two features of that guide matter for a motor finance file.

RG 273.5 states that “the best interests obligations apply only in relation to credit products that are regulated under the National Credit Act.” But the guide’s own key terms define a mortgage broker as a person who, among other things, carries on a business of providing credit assistance in relation to credit contracts “secured by mortgages over residential property,” does not act as the credit provider for most of those contracts, and provides credit assistance for contracts offered by more than one credit provider.

So the duty’s text refers to credit contracts generally, while the definition of the person the duty attaches to is framed around residential-mortgage-secured credit. RG 273 does not reconcile those two for non-mortgage consumer credit such as a car loan.

This is not a loophole. It is an unresolved question of application that turns on your specific authorisation, the business you actually carry on and the arrangement in front of you. Get your licensee’s written position on whether the best interests duty attaches to your consumer motor finance activity, and work to that position. The broader responsible lending obligations under the National Credit Act, and the conduct expectations ASIC set out in REP 832, do not wait on that question being settled.

It is also worth remembering RG 273.28, which says there is “no ‘safe harbour'” and that brokers “will need to take all steps necessary” — a reminder that where the duty does apply, process alone is not a defence.

What to review this week

None of this calls for a restructure. It calls for about ninety minutes of file hygiene on the motor and asset finance side of the business.

  1. Check what every referral partner holds. For each dealer or introducer who sends you motor finance, confirm in writing whether they hold an Australian Credit Licence, are appointed as a credit representative, or are relying on something else. ASIC’s release notes that neither penalised company had ever held a licence. A licence number you have never actually sighted is not a control.
  2. Re-read your referral agreements for who does what. The risk in this area is not the referral; it is a referrer drifting into discussing terms, collecting financial information or shaping the recommendation. Confirm your agreements say where the line sits, and that the referrer has been told.
  3. Price your own fee stack against ASIC’s published range. Pull ten recent motor finance settlements. Total every fee the client paid, split lender from distributor, and express it as a percentage of the loan. If a file sits near the top of REP 832’s range, make sure the file note explains why.
  4. Ask your lenders what their distributor oversight now looks like. ASIC says many car finance lenders have strengthened product review triggers and oversight of high-volume distributors. Ask your BDM what the triggers are and what would put you on a review list. It is a much better conversation to have before the review than during it.
  5. Get the BID position in writing. One email to your licensee: does the best interests duty attach to our consumer motor finance activity, and what documentation standard do you want on those files? File the reply.
  6. Look at early repayment problems in your own book. REP 832 treated early defaults as raising questions about whether a loan was appropriate at the outset. If any of your motor finance clients fell into arrears in the first year, understand why before someone else asks.

What to watch next

Three things will tell brokers how far this runs. First, whether ASIC follows the dealer-side enforcement with action touching an intermediary rather than a credit provider — the phrase “others who facilitate consumer finance” is an invitation to watch for it. Second, whether car finance lenders convert the REP 832 response into contractual distribution conditions, which is where a broker feels it: accreditation terms, volume thresholds, audit rights. Third, whether the BID application question for non-mortgage consumer credit gets clarified, by guidance or by a decision.

Until then the asymmetry is the thing to manage. Diversification into motor and asset finance has been the sensible commercial answer to a thin residential market, and nothing here changes that. But residential brokers moved into a sector where the conduct and licensing architecture is less settled, the fee structures are larger relative to loan size, and the regulator has just priced unlicensed lending at $6.75 million and a five-year ban.

Key Takeaways

  • The Federal Court ordered $6.75m in total penalties — $3.5m, $2.5m and $750,000 — against two car dealership companies and a director who admitted unlicensed consumer lending and charging unlawful interest. The director was also restrained from credit activities for five years.
  • Justice Lee framed the penalties as a message to “vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance.” That is a statement about deterrence and audience, not a finding about anyone who was not a party.
  • No broker or broker business was a party to the proceeding.
  • Separately, ASIC’s REP 832 found shortcomings in some lenders’ oversight of distributors including brokers and dealers — and many lenders responded by strengthening oversight of high-volume distributors.
  • REP 832 recorded distributor establishment fees from a flat $912 up to $2,500, and one example where total fees were around 18 per cent of a $49,162 loan.
  • Whether the best interests duty attaches to consumer motor finance is genuinely unsettled on the face of RG 273. Brokers should get their licensee’s written position rather than assume either answer.

Frequently Asked Questions

Nothing in ASIC’s release says that, and no broker was a party to this proceeding. What the case shows is that the Court framed deterrence broadly, addressing “vehicle dealers and others who facilitate consumer finance.” The practical response is to be clear about your own authorisation and the role you play on a motor finance file, which is a question for your licensee.

No. REP 832’s distribution finding runs the other way: ASIC found shortcomings in some lenders’ oversight of their distributors, a group that includes brokers and car dealers. The criticism is of lender monitoring. The reason it matters to brokers is that lenders fixing it means more oversight of broker files, particularly for high-volume distributors.

This article does not answer that, because RG 273 does not answer it cleanly. RG 273.5 says the obligations apply only to credit products regulated under the National Credit Act, while the guide’s definition of a mortgage broker is framed around credit secured by mortgages over residential property. How those fit together for non-mortgage consumer credit depends on your authorisation and the business you carry on. Ask your licensee for a written position and work to it.

Sight the licence status of every dealer or introducer who sends you motor finance business, and record it. ASIC’s release notes that neither penalised company had ever held an Australian Credit Licence. A licence number you have assumed but never verified is not a control, and it is the cheapest gap on the list to close.

Not on its own. Diversification remains a reasonable commercial response to a thin residential market. The point is that the conduct and licensing settings in motor finance are less settled than in residential lending, fee structures are larger relative to loan size, and ASIC is actively enforcing. That argues for the same file discipline you already apply to a home loan, not for staying out.

Breaking News for Modern Brokers

Compliance, lender policy and market shifts — read in the time between appointments.

More at The Broker Times →

Interactive · Broker Tool

Motor Finance File Readiness Check

Nine controls drawn from what ASIC’s enforcement and its car finance review actually point to. Tick what you already have in place.

Controls in place0 of 9

Start ticking

Work down the list and the read-out will tell you where the gaps sit. Nothing you tick is stored or sent anywhere — this runs entirely in your browser.

1. Who you deal with
2. Fees and disclosure
3. Obligations and oversight

This is a prompt list for your own review, not a compliance assessment and not advice. Your licensee’s requirements govern.

Compliance, lender policy and market shifts — read in the time between appointments.

More at The Broker Times →

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and professional development purposes only. It does not constitute legal, compliance, or financial advice. Brokers should consult their aggregator's compliance team and, where required, seek independent legal advice regarding their obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 and ASIC's responsible lending guidelines.