The Broker Times · Auction Finance Briefing

Victoria’s First Month of Published Reserves

2,164 residential auctions scheduled 16 October – 14 November 2026

The numbers

355
campaigns with a reserve above the advertised guide — 16.8% of the 2,115 with a guide
Broker Daily
$29,000
median gap between the top of the guide and the reserve — 2.7% above
Broker Daily
+0.9%
median result above the published reserve, for homes that sold
ABC News
7 days
minimum publication period before auction — restarted by any change
Consumer Affairs Victoria

Pass-in rate: the commercial signal

Reserve above the guide49.6%
Reserve within the guide41%

Share of properties that passed in. Where the reserve sat above the advertised range, roughly half failed to sell on the day. Broker Daily; ABC News reports 50% vs 41%.

How the seven-day clock works

1
Agent asks in writing
The agent must ask the seller, in writing, for their reserve price.
2
Published as one figure
A single dollar amount — no “from”, “over”, “+” or “starting at”.
3
Seven clear days
Published at least 7 days before the auction or fixed-date sale.
4
Any change → restart
Up or down, the clock restarts. The auction waits a further 7 days.

Two states, opposite directions

Victoria — live now
Reserve published as a single dollar figure at least 7 days before auction. CAV says the changes are in effect; ABC News and Broker Daily date the auction rule to sales held from 16 October 2026. Property Price Statement replaces the Statement of Information.
NSW — deferred
Price-advertising, comparable-sales and record-keeping reforms paused on 17 November 2026 and will now commence 1 December 2027. A deferral, not a repeal — existing underquoting duties continue.
The broker takeaway

The published reserve is the number your client has to beat — not the guide. And because any change to it restarts a seven-day clock, the auction date itself can move. That is a file-currency risk: approval expiry, valuation currency and document age all run against a date the vendor now controls.

Fundwise: compare 19 business cashflow lenders side by side. Free for brokers, no credit card, 20 free AI credits.
Compliance · Auction Finance

355 Victorian Auction Campaigns Set a Reserve Above the Guide. A Reserve Change Restarts the Seven-Day Clock — and RG 273.121 Is About Delay

Victoria now makes agents publish the vendor’s reserve as a single dollar figure a week before auction. The first month of data is in — and the part brokers should be reading is not the headline number.

In this article

  1. What Victoria actually changed
  2. What the first month of data says — both readings
  3. The mechanic nobody is pricing: the restarted clock
  4. Where that lands on your file
  5. The pre-auction side door
  6. NSW just went the other way
  7. What to review this week

The short version: For the first time in an Australian auction market, your client can see the number the property has to beat — seven days out, as a single dollar figure. That is a better pre-approval conversation than brokers have ever had at auction. It also introduces a timing variable that can push an auction date back a week at a time, which is a file-currency problem rather than a pricing one.

What Victoria actually changed

Consumer Affairs Victoria’s industry guidance, last updated 21 October 2026, states that the new property sales and underquoting changes “are now in effect”. Both ABC News and Broker Daily date the auction-specific requirement to sales held from 16 October 2026.

The obligation sits on the agent, not the vendor. Under the CAV guidance, real estate agents must ask the seller, in writing, to provide their reserve price. Agents must then publish the seller’s reserve price “at least 7 days before an auction or fixed-date sale”.

Three details matter more to a broker than the headline:

  • It must be a single dollar amount. CAV says the price must be “a single dollar amount, without words or symbols such as ‘from’, ‘over’, ‘+’ or ‘starting at’”. Once published, only the reserve should be displayed as the advertised price, and online advertising must be updated within one business day of the agent receiving it.
  • A change restarts the clock. A change to the published reserve — up or down — restarts the seven-day period. Per CAV, the auction “cannot take place until the revised reserve price has been publicly available for a further 7 days”.
  • Non-compliance stops the event. Where the reserve has not been published as required, CAV’s stated consequence is that “the auction or fixed-date sale cannot go ahead”.

The same reform package replaces the Statement of Information with a Property Price Statement, which must carry both the indicative selling price and the reserve. CAV also states that agents who fail to publish sold prices as required “may face maximum penalties of 240 penalty units, currently $48,842”. That penalty figure attaches to the sold-price obligation specifically, not to the reserve-publication rule — worth keeping straight if a client or referral partner repeats it to you as a general auction penalty.

A note on sourcing: CAV’s industry Q&A does not name the amending Act or the principal Act it amends, and we have not been able to verify the instrument from the regulator’s own material. We have therefore described the obligations as the regulator describes them, without citing a section number. Confirm the instrument with your licensee before relying on it in a compliance document.

What the first month of data says — both readings

Property platform Homer tracked residential auctions in the first month of the new regime. Both ABC News and Broker Daily report the same sample: 2,164 residential auctions scheduled between 16 October and 14 November 2026.

The two outlets framed it very differently, and brokers should hold both framings at once.

The optimistic reading (ABC News, 19 November). Homer chief executive and co-founder Henry Pedersen told ABC News: “The short version is yes, the data does suggest transparency is working.” He said “buyers and sellers are landing very close to what was advertised”, with properties that sold going for a median 0.9 per cent above the published reserve, and more than three-quarters of homes sold carrying a reserve within the advertised range. Pedersen added, after reviewing the data, that “three in four reserves now sit inside the guide”, down from about one in five above the range to about one in seven.

The cautious reading (Broker Daily, 20 November). On Broker Daily’s figures, 2,115 of those campaigns had a published price guide, and 355 of them — 16.8 per cent — carried a reserve above the advertised range. The median gap between the top of the guide and the reserve was $29,000, or 2.7 per cent. For the 83 campaigns where the reserve sat at least 5 per cent above the guide, the median gap was $70,000 in the 5–10 per cent band and $110,000 above 10 per cent.

Note the discrepancy, because it is the kind of thing that gets repeated loosely: ABC describes the above-range share as about one in seven, while Broker Daily’s arithmetic gives 16.8 per cent, closer to one in six. ABC does not state its denominator. We have attributed each figure to the outlet that published it rather than averaging them into a single claim.

Both outlets agree on the number that matters most commercially. Where the reserve sat above the advertised range, roughly half the properties passed in — 49.6 per cent on Broker Daily’s figures, 50 per cent on ABC’s — against 41 per cent where the reserve sat within the range.

Independent property economist Cameron Kusher put the appropriate guardrail on all of it, telling ABC News: “It’s hard to read too much into five weeks of data, in a down market, but it’s about what you’d expect.” He noted that “people with more urgency to sell are the ones taking things to auction right now”. One month, in a falling market, is not a trend.

Pedersen’s line to Broker Daily is the one to read twice, because it is a description of a broker’s Tuesday: “A buyer approved to the top of the guide can find the reserve out of reach a week before auction.”

The mechanic nobody is pricing: the restarted clock

Almost all of the commentary on this reform has been about price transparency — whether buyers are better informed. That is the consumer question. The broker question is different, and it has had almost no airtime.

Under CAV’s guidance, a vendor who moves the reserve in either direction triggers a fresh seven-day publication period, and the auction cannot proceed until that period has run. In a falling market, with pass-in rates at or near half for above-guide reserves, there is now a live incentive for vendors to revise a reserve down late in a campaign.

Which means the auction date is no longer a fixed point you can plan a file around. It is contingent on vendor behaviour in the final fortnight.

For a broker, that is not a pricing problem. It is a file-currency problem, and it hits three things at once:

  • Approval expiry. A conditional approval issued against an original auction date can sit awkwardly against a date that has moved seven days, or fourteen.
  • Valuation currency. A valuation ordered for one auction date, in a market Cotality has recorded falling for a seventh consecutive month, is a different instrument two weeks later.
  • Supporting documents. Payslips, statements and servicing evidence all age against a date that is no longer under anyone’s control but the vendor’s.

Where that lands on your file

This is where it stops being market commentary and becomes a best interests duty question. The following is general information about what ASIC’s guidance says, not advice on your obligations — confirm the application to your own process with your licensee or compliance adviser.

ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 273 speaks directly to delay. RG 273.121 says that where the process is delayed, “you should consider whether you need to start a new assessment or make further inquiries”. RG 273.122 sets out the factors, including “the length of the delay” and “whether the information considered is reasonably current and likely to still reflect the consumer’s circumstances”. A note to that paragraph records that the responsible lending obligations “require you to undertake inquiries within 90 days of credit assistance being provided”.

A single seven-day restart will rarely trouble a 90-day window. Two or three, on a campaign that was already six weeks old when you issued the approval, is a different proposition — and RG 273.121 frames that as something you should actively consider rather than something that simply happens to the file.

RG 273.43 is the companion paragraph. Where a consumer discloses a change in circumstances, it says “you should clarify these circumstances with the consumer” and “consider whether there is a need to change the content of the credit assistance you provide”. A reserve published $70,000 above the guide your client was approved against is not a change in their circumstances — but it is very likely to produce one, because it changes what they are now contemplating bidding.

Two more paragraphs are worth having at hand for auction files generally. RG 273.77 acknowledges that “some consumers will prioritise approval time and compromise on cost because of a time-sensitive transaction” — useful framing when a client’s best option on paper cannot deliver inside the window. And RG 273.73(c) lists “the term and structure of the credit product relative to the consumer’s objectives” among the relevant factors, which is the hook for the structural conversations a disclosed reserve tends to open: a larger deposit, a different LVR band, or a guarantor.

On records, RG 273.169 is explicit that taking notes “throughout the process (contemporaneously)” is more effective than “drafting notes and creating records at the end”. A published reserve is a dated, documentable event in a campaign. It is unusually easy to file a contemporaneous note against.

The pre-auction side door

There is a second-order effect in the CAV guidance that deserves more attention than it is getting. Pre-auction offers are treated as private sales and do not require the seven-day period. A “boardroom auction”, by contrast, counts as a fixed-date sale and needs the full seven days. For off-market sales, the seven-day reserve advertising does not apply, though the Property Price Statement and sold-price publication obligations do.

Put that beside a roughly 50 per cent pass-in rate for above-guide reserves and the incentive is obvious: a vendor who has just published a reserve the market may not meet has a reason to transact before auction day, through a channel that carries no waiting period.

That is a broker workflow consequence. Pre-auction offers compress into days, not weeks, and they land on brokers as urgent requests for finance certainty. If a measurable share of Victorian campaigns starts resolving before auction, the practical effect is more short-notice approvals on files that were built around a date that never arrived.

Scott Baker, founder of Geelong-based Toast Finance, described the broader job to Broker Daily this way: “Other than just organising a pre-approval, a big part of what we do is education around how to buy at auctions.” Under the new regime, that education now has a hard number in it.

NSW just went the other way

Here is the part that makes this a national story rather than a Victorian one. In the same week Victoria’s first month of reserve data landed, New South Wales pulled back from its own pre-auction price reforms.

A NSW Fair Trading release dated 17 November 2026 states that the government is pausing the commencement of changes relating to price advertisements, agency agreements, setting and reviewing estimated selling prices based on comparable properties, prescribed record-keeping obligations, the Statement of Information, and the continuing professional development approved provider framework. Its heading reads: “New laws for property and stock agents will now commence 1 December 2027.”

The precise status matters, and it has been reported loosely elsewhere. This is a deferral of commencement to a fixed date — 1 December 2027 — not a repeal and not a scrapping. Existing NSW underquoting obligations continue: agents must keep the estimated price reasonable, revise it when it is no longer reasonable, and not advertise or quote below the estimate in the agency agreement.

The tranche that had been due to commence on 17 November 2026 would, per the 1 November ministerial release, have required a selling price or price range on residential advertisements, updates to online ads within one business day where a displayed price no longer complied, use of the three most comparable sales when setting an estimate, detailed records of how the estimate was determined, and a maximum underquoting penalty of $110,000 or three times the agent’s commission, whichever is greater.

Whether that penalty increase is itself paused is the one point the official 17 November release does not settle; it lists the paused items without naming penalties, while trade reporting states the fines are paused too. Separately, the NSW release notes that certain offences already in force since 29 June 2026 carry maximums of $110,000 for a corporation and $55,000 for an individual — including acting as an agent without a licence and dummy bidding at auctions. Those were not paused.

As to why, Real Estate Business reported Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading Anoulack Chanthivong saying: “Parliament passed these laws at a different time and in a different economic and housing market.” NSW Premier Chris Minns was reported as saying: “It’s not the seller or the agent’s fault if the price of real estate is dropping.”

For brokers writing in both states — and for aggregator groups running one auction playbook nationally — that is an asymmetry with a thirteen-month life. A Melbourne client gets a published dollar figure seven days out. A Sydney client gets a price guide and an estimate, with the comparable-sales and record-keeping discipline now more than a year away. The same conversation, with materially different information behind it.

Key takeaways

  • Victorian agents must publish the vendor’s reserve as a single dollar figure at least seven days before an auction or fixed-date sale, per Consumer Affairs Victoria.
  • In the first month, Broker Daily reported 355 of 2,115 campaigns with a guide (16.8 per cent) carried a reserve above the advertised range, median gap $29,000; ABC News described the share as about one in seven and reported sold homes landing a median 0.9 per cent above the published reserve.
  • Where the reserve sat above the range, roughly half of properties passed in, against 41 per cent where it sat within the range.
  • A change to a published reserve restarts the seven-day period, so the auction date can move — a file-currency risk, not a pricing one. RG 273.121 says that where the process is delayed you should consider whether to start a new assessment or make further inquiries.
  • NSW deferred its comparable parcel of price-advertising and record-keeping reforms to 1 December 2027. That is a deferral, not a repeal, and existing underquoting obligations continue.

What to review this week

Five things, none of which require a system change:

  1. Pull your live Victorian auction files and check the published reserve against the approved amount. Not the guide — the reserve. That number is now public seven days out, and on Broker Daily’s figures roughly one in six sits above the range the client was probably approved against.
  2. Add the reserve publication date to your file notes. It is a dated, verifiable campaign event, and RG 273.169 favours contemporaneous records over notes written at the end.
  3. Diarise approval expiry against a movable auction date. If the vendor revises the reserve, the auction shifts by at least seven days. Know which of your files has the least headroom before documents or valuations go stale.
  4. Brief clients on the ceiling, not the guide. The disclosed reserve is the number to beat. A client approved to the top of the guide needs to hear that before auction week, not during it.
  5. Prepare for pre-auction offers. They are treated as private sales with no seven-day period. Decide now how fast your process can genuinely move, so the answer is not improvised under pressure.

The strategic read

Brokers have spent years managing a gap between the advertised guide and the price a property actually needed. In Victoria, for the first time, that gap is published. The honest assessment of the first month is that it is working better than the sceptics expected and is far too early to call — both of which are compatible with Kusher’s point that five weeks in a falling market tells you very little.

But the lasting change for brokers is not the transparency. It is that a vendor’s decision now moves an auction date, and the broker owns the consequences of that on a file nobody else is watching. The reform was written to protect buyers from a number that was too low. The operational risk it has handed brokers is a date that will not sit still.

That is worth a process, not a reaction. The brokers who handle this well in the next quarter will be the ones who treated a published reserve as a diary event rather than a talking point.

Breaking news for modern brokers

Lender policy shifts, regulator moves and market data — read through a broker’s file, twice a day.

More at The Broker Times →
Interactive · Broker Tool

The Pre-Auction File Check

Pick the situation in front of you. Each one carries a different file consequence under the new Victorian rules.

The common case

ABC News reported that more than three-quarters of homes sold in the first month carried a reserve within the advertised range, and that sold properties landed a median 0.9% above the published reserve. Pass-in rate for this group: 41%.

What it means for the file

  • Your approval and the client’s realistic ceiling are probably aligned. Confirm it rather than assume it.
  • Note the reserve publication date on the file while the campaign is live — RG 273.169 favours contemporaneous records.
  • Still diarise the auction date against approval expiry. A revision can move it at any point.

This week’s file review

0 of 5 complete

This checklist is a prompt, not a compliance process. Confirm how any of it applies to your obligations with your licensee or compliance adviser.

More broker briefings →
Fundwise: compare 19 business cashflow lenders side by side. Free for brokers, no credit card, 20 free AI credits.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and professional development purposes only. It does not constitute legal, compliance, or financial advice. Brokers should consult their aggregator’s compliance team and, where required, seek independent legal advice regarding their obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 and ASIC’s responsible lending guidelines.