Borrower Behaviour · November 2026

Three in Five Mortgage Holders Did Not Look at Their Loan

Two surveys and one national dataset landed within a week of each other. Read together, they say the refinance market is not growing — it is narrowing, and the thing blocking it is not price.

Two numbers moving in opposite directions

▼

Owner-occupier external refinancing

$40.6b September quarter 2026, seasonally adjusted. Down 3.3% on the June quarter and 3.4% on a year earlier. Investor refinancing fell 6.5% and 5.7% on the same measures (ABS).
▲

One network’s refinancing volumes

+8% Year-on-year across the Mortgage Choice franchise network, led by double-digit growth in Queensland and Western Australia. A network’s own submissions, not a national measure.

The review gap

Only two in five borrowers reviewed their home loan in the past year — across a year in which the RBA lifted the cash rate four times, from 3.60% to 4.60%.

A fifth increase, to 4.85%, landed on 4 November, after the survey closed.

Why the other three in five did not

Paperwork and time25%
Doubt the savings are worth the effort25%
Break or discharge fees19%
Loyalty to their lender13%
Not knowing where to start12.5%
Friction or doubt — a broker can remove both before the first call A cost that is knowable in advance

What the guidance already asks you to produce

RG 273.118
The duty does not require a periodic review. It attaches when you choose to review, or when a past client contacts you. The stale file is an unworked book, not a breach.
RG 273.58
Refinancing expenses may exceed the savings. The consumer may benefit from being told about minor savings, with an explanation of when those savings would exceed the costs.
REP 840
Licensees measured loan cost over different horizons — some 25 to 30 years, some five. The horizon you quote changes whether a saving looks worth it.

The pressure behind it

Cutting back to meet repayments

70% Seven in 10 borrowers, up 4 percentage points in six months. Mostly discretionary: eating out 33%, non-essential purchases 30%, entertainment 30%, holidays 24%.

Confident of meeting repayments

75% Over the next 12 months. Baby Boomers 87%, Gen Z 67%. A book under pressure, not a book in distress.

Would feel more confident switching with a broker

55% Two in three already feel confident switching. Of borrowers who went direct to their lender, 51% felt their options were limited.

“Mortgage holders continue to show a quiet resilience to manage rising rates.”

Anthony Waldron, Chief Executive Officer, Mortgage Choice — as reported by Broker Daily, 17 November 2026

The takeaway

Half of the borrowers who did not review their loan were stopped by paperwork or by doubt that the saving was worth it. Both are things you can settle before you pick up the phone — and RG 273.58 already asks you to produce the number that answers the second one, including when the answer is “stay where you are”.

Sources: ABS, Lending indicators, September quarter 2026 (released 11 November 2026); Mortgage Choice Home Loan Report, drawing on franchise submission data and an October 2026 survey of 1,000 consumers, as reported by Broker Daily, 17 November 2026; RBA, cash rate target series, and Minutes of the Monetary Policy Board Meeting, 2–3 November 2026 (published 17 November 2026); ASIC Regulatory Guide 273 Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty; ASIC Report 840 Mortgage brokers: Review of best interests duty and complaints handling practices (13 October 2026).
Fundwise: compare 19 business cashflow lenders side by side. Free for brokers, no credit card, 20 free AI credits.
Growth Retention & Database 18 November 2026

Two in Five Borrowers Reviewed Their Loan Last Year. Paperwork and Doubt the Saving Is Worth It Each Stopped 25% of the Rest

National refinancing is falling while at least one franchise network’s refinancing volumes are rising. The survey published this week explains the gap — and the two biggest blockers are both things a broker can clear before the first call.

Two measures of refinancing published within a week of each other point in opposite directions. Both can be right. Read together, they describe a market that is not expanding but concentrating — and a survey released on Tuesday names, in the borrowers’ own words, exactly what is holding the rest of them still.

Two numbers that disagree

On 11 November the Australian Bureau of Statistics published lending indicators for the September quarter. External refinancing of owner-occupier housing loans came in at $40.6 billion on a seasonally adjusted basis, down 3.3% on the June quarter and down 3.4% on the September quarter of 2025. Investor external refinancing was $23.4 billion, down 6.5% on the quarter and 5.7% on the year. Total new housing loan commitments fell 15.5% in the quarter to $81.2 billion.

On 17 November, Broker Daily reported the latest Mortgage Choice Home Loan Report — a twice-yearly publication that combines the franchise network’s own submission data with a consumer survey, in this case of 1,000 respondents in October 2026. It put the network’s national refinancing volumes up 8% year-on-year, with double-digit growth in Queensland and Western Australia.

The two are not in conflict, and it is worth being precise about why. The ABS counts the dollar value of commitments across the whole economy. The aggregator counts its own lodgement volumes. Different units, different populations, and the periods behind each are not stated identically. So the comparison is directional, not arithmetic — nobody should take 8% growth in one network as evidence of a national turn.

What it does suggest is a narrowing. Fewer borrowers in total are moving, and the ones who still move look more likely to be moving through somebody who does the work for them. The same report puts a number on that too: 75% of borrowers who used a broker felt it gave them more options, while among those who went directly to their lender, 51% felt their options were limited.

The review gap: three in five did not look

The single most useful figure in the report is also the bluntest. Only two in five borrowers reviewed their home loan in the past year.

Consider the backdrop. In the twelve months to that October survey, the Reserve Bank lifted the cash rate target four times — to 3.85% on 4 February, 4.10% on 18 March, 4.35% on 6 May and 4.60% on 30 September. A fifth increase, to 4.85%, took effect on 4 November, after the survey closed. That is 100 basis points of tightening inside the survey window and 125 across the calendar year.

Through all of that, three in five mortgage holders did not open their loan at all.

This is not a book under compliance risk. It is a book nobody has worked.

The blockers are friction and doubt, not rate

Where the report earns its keep is in asking the non-reviewers why. Their answers, as reported:

Stated barriers to switching lenders among borrowers who had not reviewed their loan. Source: Mortgage Choice Home Loan Report, October 2026 survey of 1,000 consumers, as reported by Broker Daily, 17 November 2026.
Stated barrierShareWhat it actually is
Paperwork and time25%Process friction
Doubt the savings are worth the effort25%An unanswered calculation
Break or discharge fees19%A cost that is knowable in advance
Loyalty to their lender13%A relationship judgement
Not knowing where to start12.5%Process friction

Read the first column again. Not one of those five answers is “my rate is fine”. The two largest, at a quarter each, are paperwork and scepticism. Add “not knowing where to start” to the paperwork group and roughly 37.5% of non-reviewers are stopped by process rather than by price at all.

That matters because of how most reactivation campaigns are written. The standard email leads with the rate environment — rates have moved again, would you like me to take a look? — and then asks the client to do the one thing they have already told a surveyor they will not do: find documents and spend time. The message answers an objection nobody raised and restates the two that were.

The reframe

If a quarter of your dormant book is blocked by paperwork and a quarter by doubt about the size of the prize, the winning approach is not a sharper rate line. It is removing the work and pre-answering the doubt: I have already run your loan against the panel. Here is the number. If you want it, I need two documents and about fifteen minutes.

Why there is no duty to review — and why that matters

A persistent misconception is that an unreviewed past client is a compliance exposure. Generally, it is not. ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 273 is direct on the point.

RG 273.118
“The best interests duty does not require you to conduct a ‘periodic review’, or to provide credit assistance to the consumer in the future. However, it is good practice to review the consumer’s circumstances from time to time. If you choose to review the consumer’s circumstances, or you are contacted by a consumer you previously assisted, then the best interests duty will apply to any credit assistance you provide at that time.”

Two consequences follow, and they pull in the same direction.

First, the review gap is a commercial problem rather than a regulatory one. Nothing in the duty compels an annual check-in, so no broker is behind on an obligation because a 2023 client has not been contacted. The cost of the gap is revenue and retention, not enforcement.

Second, the duty does attach the moment you act. Once you open the file or the client calls you, best interests applies to whatever credit assistance follows — including a recommendation to stay put. So the reactivation conversation has to be built to be documented, not bolted onto a marketing send. The practical implication is that a reactivation program and a file-note standard need to be designed together, because the campaign generates the files.

The “is it worth it” question is one ASIC already asks you to answer

Here is the part worth sitting with. A quarter of borrowers who did not review their loan said they doubted the savings justified the effort. RG 273 contains guidance that asks the broker to produce precisely the figure that settles that doubt.

RG 273.58
“For consumers who are thinking about refinancing an existing loan, the expenses incurred when refinancing may exceed the cost savings of a new loan. In this situation, recommending a new loan may not be in the consumer’s best interests. The consumer may benefit from being made aware of any potentially minor cost savings associated with refinancing, with an explanation of when the cost savings would exceed the refinancing expenses.”

Note what that paragraph contemplates. Not only the case where refinancing stacks up, but the case where it does not — and in that case, telling the client the saving is small and explaining the conditions under which it would stop being small. A payback period, in other words, and a trigger.

That is a retention asset dressed as a compliance note. The broker who can say “I have run it — you would save roughly $340 a year, the discharge and establishment costs come to about $900, so it pays back in a bit under three years; if your lender moves another 15 basis points without passing on a cut, that falls under two” has given the client a reason to act and a reason to call back if nothing changes. The broker who asks whether the client would like them to take a look has handed the work back.

RG 273.120 is the companion obligation, and it is short: “For consumers who may be thinking about refinancing, you should consider the costs associated with refinancing.” Those costs are the third-largest stated barrier in the survey — break or discharge fees, at 19% — and they are knowable before any client conversation begins. A borrower guessing at their break cost will almost always guess badly. Guessing is what the 19% is made of.

The horizon problem REP 840 exposed

There is a trap in answering “is the saving worth it”, and ASIC documented it last month. Report 840, published on 13 October, reviewed 13 credit licensees making up eight large aggregator groups, covering around two-thirds of all broker representatives, using data from 1 April 2023 to 31 March 2025.

Two findings bear directly on this conversation. The first is scale: seven of the eight groups reported that brokers did not recommend the lowest cost loan in more than 20% of cases over the review period. Non-cost reasons — a required feature, a lender’s credit policy, turnaround times — are legitimate, and RG 273.56 and RG 273.57 both make clear that the lowest rate is not necessarily the lowest cost and that cost is not the only relevant factor. But ASIC expects the reasoning on file.

The second finding is the measurement problem. ASIC found that licensees “were calculating loan costs in different ways, with some licensees considering cost over the full term of the loan (e.g. 25 to 30 years) and others considering it over a shorter period (e.g. 5 years) to more closely reflect how long consumers tend to remain in a loan”.

That is not a technicality. It decides the answer. Quoted over thirty years, a modest rate gap produces a headline saving large enough to make almost any switch look compelling. Quoted over five years — closer to how long borrowers actually hold a loan — the same gap can land at a few hundred dollars a year against real switching costs. ASIC leaned to the shorter view in its own analysis, converting full-term figures to a five-year reference period, and even then noted that five years “may overstate the cost actually incurred by consumers who roll off low introductory rates and seek to avoid higher reversion rates through refinancing”.

And the regulator’s concern scaled with the stakes. Where the projected five-year cost difference between the recommended loan and the cheapest option compared exceeded $20,000, ASIC recorded its highest level of concern about the adequacy of the broker’s recorded reasons in 43.9% of the loans it sampled, with no concerns in 34.1%. Below $1,000 of difference, 74.1% drew no concerns.

What this means in practice

If you are going to answer a client’s “is it worth it” with a number, state the horizon you used and keep it consistent across the book. A saving quoted over thirty years to win the conversation, sitting on a file where the client refinances again in four, is a reasoning gap waiting to be found — and it is the exact gap REP 840 says licensees were not monitoring. ASIC noted that none of the licensees reviewed used metrics comparing the cost of the recommended loan against the other loans the broker considered.

This is general information about published guidance, not advice on your own obligations. Your licensee’s policy sets the standard you are assessed against — check it before you change how you quote.

Reading 70% correctly

The headline figure from the report is that seven in 10 borrowers are cutting back on spending to keep up with repayments, with the share making sacrifices up four percentage points over six months. It is tempting to read that as a book sliding toward hardship. The rest of the data says otherwise.

The cuts are weighted to discretionary spending: 33% eating out less, 30% cutting non-essential purchases, 30% cutting entertainment, 24% delaying or cancelling holidays. Essentials sit behind them — 22% cutting groceries or household essentials, 20% driving less to save on fuel. And 75% of mortgage holders say they are confident they can meet repayments over the next 12 months, though with a wide generational spread: 87% of Baby Boomers against 67% of Gen Z borrowers.

The RBA’s own read, in the minutes of its 2–3 November meeting published on 17 November, is consistent. Scheduled loan repayments as a share of household disposable income “had risen to around their 2024 peak”, while offset and redraw balances were “perhaps supporting consumption by mortgage holders”. Pressure, with buffers.

For a broker the operational consequence is less about hardship referrals and more about the fact-find. A client who has stripped several hundred dollars a month of discretionary spending to hold a repayment will present lower declared living expenses than the same client a year ago — which means benchmark floors will do more of the work in servicing, and the gap between declared expenses and the benchmark becomes the thing that needs evidencing.

That makes benchmark changes worth diarising. Granite Home Loans is updating Household Expenditure Measure figures across all its servicing calculators from 23 November, with applications received before 11:59pm on 22 November able to use the existing figures, per Broker Daily’s lender policy round-up for 9–13 November. Pipeline files either side of a date like that can be assessed on different benchmarks.

One more finding worth a note

A third of prospective buyers in the survey said they plan to share their home with family, housemates or boarders who contribute to living costs, and 61% of those plans involve multigenerational living with parents or adult children moving in. Mortgage Choice chief executive Anthony Waldron framed it as the “Great Australian Dream… changing shape, not disappearing”.

The broker consequence is a shortlisting one. How board, rent-from-family or household-contribution income is treated varies considerably across a lender panel, and a purchase plan that leans on it needs that treatment confirmed against the specific lenders in play before a recommendation is made — not discovered at assessment. Check each lender’s current policy rather than assuming the panel is consistent.

What to review this week

  1. Measure your own review gap. Run a CRM query for clients settled 18 months or more ago with no recorded contact in the past 12. That count, against your total book, is your version of the three-in-five figure. It is the number that sizes the opportunity.
  2. Rank by payback, not rate differential. A 40-basis-point gap on a $300,000 balance with a fixed break cost is a worse prospect than a 20-basis-point gap on $900,000 with none. Sort the list by how fast the switch pays for itself.
  3. Pre-compute the switching cost before you make contact. Discharge fee, new application and settlement costs, any break cost, and whether LMI would be re-triggered. Nineteen per cent of non-reviewers named fees as their blocker; arrive with the figure rather than the offer to find it.
  4. Fix your horizon and write it down. Decide whether you quote savings over five years or the full term, apply it consistently, and record which you used. REP 840 is explicit that this choice varies across the industry and that licensees were not monitoring it.
  5. Rewrite the opening line. Lead with the result and the effort, not the rate environment. “I have run your loan” beats “rates have moved”, and naming the two documents and the minutes required answers the paperwork objection directly.
  6. Build the “stay put” file note. Have a template that records the comparison, the costs, the conclusion that refinancing is not in the client’s interests now, and the condition that would change that — the structure RG 273.58 describes. Most reactivation conversations will end here, and those files need to be as defensible as the ones that convert.
  7. Look at your book by state. If Queensland and Western Australia are driving refinance growth elsewhere, check whether your own geographic mix has shifted and whether your lender accreditations and valuation experience match where the activity actually is.

What to watch next

  • The rate path. The November minutes show the board split six to three, with three members preferring to hold at 4.60%. The minutes note markets were pricing the cash rate around 35 basis points higher than its then-current level by mid-2027. Westpac chief economist Luci Ellis argued in a 13 November note, as reported by The Adviser, that a further increase “would be unlikely and — we would argue — undesirable”. The fixed-versus-variable conversation turns on which of those views a client believes.
  • The December-quarter lending indicators. They will show whether external refinancing kept falling after the November increase, and whether the broker share of what remains is still climbing.
  • Licensee monitoring changes following REP 840. ASIC said no reviewed licensee used metrics comparing the recommended loan’s cost against the alternatives considered. If aggregators build those exception reports, the first brokers to feel it will be those recommending above the cheapest option without recorded reasoning.

Key takeaways

  • National external refinancing fell in the September quarter — owner-occupier down 3.3% to $40.6 billion, investor down 6.5% to $23.4 billion — while one franchise network reported its own refinancing volumes up 8% year-on-year. The market looks to be concentrating rather than growing.
  • Only two in five borrowers reviewed their home loan in the past year, across a window containing four cash rate increases.
  • The two largest stated barriers among those who did not review were paperwork and time (25%) and doubt the savings were worth the effort (25%). Rate was not among the reasons given.
  • RG 273.118 confirms the best interests duty does not require a periodic review — so the gap is a commercial opportunity, though the duty attaches as soon as you act.
  • RG 273.58 asks brokers to quantify small savings and explain when they would exceed refinancing costs. That calculation is the direct answer to the 25% who doubt it is worth it.
  • REP 840 found licensees measuring loan cost over different horizons, from five years to the full term. The horizon you quote decides whether a saving looks worthwhile, so fix it and record it.
Sources. Australian Bureau of Statistics, Lending indicators, September quarter 2026, released 11 November 2026 (seasonally adjusted series). Mortgage Choice Home Loan Report, drawing on franchise network submission data and an October 2026 survey of 1,000 consumers, together with quotes from chief executive Anthony Waldron, as reported by Broker Daily, “Borrowers tighten belts and lean on brokers amid hikes”, 17 November 2026 — the figures attributed to that report were not independently verified against the report itself. Reserve Bank of Australia, cash rate target series, and Minutes of the Monetary Policy Board Meeting, 2–3 November 2026, published 17 November 2026. ASIC Regulatory Guide 273 Mortgage brokers: Best interests duty, paragraphs 273.56, 273.57, 273.58, 273.118 and 273.120. ASIC Report 840 Mortgage brokers: Review of best interests duty and complaints handling practices, published 13 October 2026, including Table 4. Granite Home Loans and lender policy dates per Broker Daily, “Broker policy round-up: Lender changes at a glance 9–13 November”. Westpac forecast commentary attributed to chief economist Luci Ellis via The Adviser, “Westpac more convinced rates have peaked as economy weakens”, 17 November 2026.

Breaking news and practical analysis for modern brokers.

More at The Broker Times →
Broker Tool

The Payback Question, Answered Before You Call

A quarter of borrowers who skipped a loan review said they doubted the saving was worth the effort. This works that out, shows how the answer changes with the horizon you quote, and drafts the file note RG 273.58 describes — including when the answer is “stay put”.

Discharge, application, settlement, any break cost
REP 840 found licensees using different horizons

Payback period

— Until the saving covers the switching cost

Saving, year one

— Interest only, on today’s balance

Saving over horizon

— Net of switching costs

Rate gap

— Basis points
Enter the numbers and select “Work it out” The calculator will also draft a file note in the shape RG 273.58 describes.

Draft file note

Awaiting inputs.

Indicative only. This is a simple interest-based estimate on a static balance. It ignores amortisation, repayment type, fee structures, offset and redraw behaviour, reversion rates and any change in the cash rate — all of which affect the real answer. RG 273.56 notes the product with the lowest interest rate is not necessarily the lowest cost option. Use your aggregator’s approved comparison tool for anything that goes on a client file, and follow your licensee’s policy on how savings are calculated and recorded.

Practical analysis for brokers, twice a day.

More at The Broker Times →
Fundwise: compare 19 business cashflow lenders side by side. Free for brokers, no credit card, 20 free AI credits.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and professional development purposes only. It does not constitute legal, compliance, or financial advice. Brokers should consult their aggregator’s compliance team and, where required, seek independent legal advice regarding their obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 and ASIC’s responsible lending guidelines.