Consumer Sentiment · November 2026

Two Numbers Moved in Opposite Directions

Mortgage-holder sentiment fell to the lowest reading since the series began in 1994 — while the share of consumers expecting further mortgage rate rises eased for the first time since September.

The divergence

▼

Mortgage-holder sentiment

68.1 Down 11.6% in November. A record low on Westpac–Melbourne Institute measures going back to 1994.
▲

Expect rates to rise in 12 months

72% Down from 80% in October — but still well above the 64% recorded in September.
64%
Sep
80%
Oct
72%
Nov
Share of surveyed consumers expecting mortgage rates to increase over the next 12 months.

What households say about themselves

61%
Say their family finances are worse off than a year ago — a record high for that ANZ–Roy Morgan indicator
17%
Expect to be better off in 12 months — tied for a record low
63.1
ANZ–Roy Morgan Consumer Confidence, down 3.1 points and 8.5 below the 2026 weekly average of 71.6
14%
Say it is a good time to buy major household items, against 48% who say it is a bad time

The demand data behind it

−15.5%
Value of new housing loan commitments, September quarter, to $81.2bn (ABS)
−32.3%
Investor commitments by value in the quarter, against −5.3% for owner-occupiers (ABS)
0.80%
CBA home loans more than 90 days overdue, up 7 basis points in the quarter
4.85%
Cash rate target from 3 November, a 25bp increase carried six votes to three

Capacity problem or willingness problem?

1

A capacity constraint looks like declines, workarounds and re-submissions. The client wants to borrow and policy says no.

2

A willingness constraint looks like silence. Appointments that do not convert, pre-approvals that lapse unused, clients who say they will wait and see.

3

The tell in your own numbers: appointments holding while applications fall. That is conversion, not lead flow.

The file point. When 72% expect rate rises, more clients ask to fix. When a record 61% say they are already worse off, some of those are asking for a lower repayment, not rate certainty. RG 273.76 notes a fixed rate loan with a substantial break fee could be detrimental to a consumer who wants flexibility to refinance. Which client is in front of you — and did you ask?

The takeaway

Rate-rise fear eased eight percentage points in a month while households’ assessment of their own finances hit records in the other direction. Brokers spent 2026 solving capacity. The constraint now is a client who has the capacity and has lost the confidence.

Sources: Westpac–Melbourne Institute Index of Consumer Sentiment, November 2026 (released 10 November 2026); ANZ–Roy Morgan Consumer Confidence (released 10 November 2026); ABS, Lending indicators, September quarter 2026 (released 11 November 2026); RBA, Statement by the Monetary Policy Board, 3 November 2026; ASIC Regulatory Guide 273; CBA first-quarter FY2026–27 trading update (11 November 2026) as reported by The Adviser.

Fundwise: compare 19 business cashflow lenders side by side. Free for brokers, no credit card, 20 free AI credits.
News Borrower Demand 15 November 2026

Mortgage-Holder Sentiment Fell 11.6% to a Record 68.1 While Rate-Rise Fear Eased From 80% to 72%

Those two numbers moved in opposite directions in the same week — and they point at two different client conversations.

Mortgage holders have never been more pessimistic on the Westpac–Melbourne Institute series, yet fewer of them expect rates to keep rising. The driver of client hesitation has shifted from the next cash rate decision to the household’s own finances — which changes the pitch, the product conversation and what belongs on the file.

Two Australian consumer surveys landed on 10 November, and read together they say something that has not yet been said plainly: mortgage holders have never been more pessimistic, and the thing they are pessimistic about has changed. The share of consumers expecting mortgage rates to rise over the next 12 months fell. Mortgage-holder sentiment collapsed anyway.

That is not a contradiction. It is a shift in what is holding your clients back — and it points at a different conversation from the one most brokers have been having since the middle of the year.

What was published

The Westpac–Melbourne Institute Index of Consumer Sentiment for November 2026 fell 2.7 per cent to 78.2, from 80.4 in October. Within that survey, the sub-group covering consumers with a mortgage fell 11.6 per cent to 68.1 — which Westpac describes as a record low on measures going back to 1994. Matthew Hassan, Westpac’s head of Australian macro-forecasting, wrote that “Australian consumers remain deeply pessimistic, sentiment continuing to plumb extreme lows.”

The same survey reported the Mortgage Rate Expectations Index at 177.8, down 1.1 per cent and still near recent peaks. But the underlying share matters more than the index: 72 per cent of respondents expected mortgage rates to rise over the next 12 months, against 80 per cent in October and 64 per cent in September.

The ANZ–Roy Morgan weekly Consumer Confidence reading, also released on 10 November, fell 3.1 points to 63.1 — 8.5 points below the 2026 weekly average of 71.6. ANZ economist Sophia Angala described it as the third-lowest result since the series began in 1973. Confidence fell across every housing cohort, and mortgage-holder confidence fell to its lowest level since that weekly series began in 2008.

The component detail in the ANZ–Roy Morgan survey is where the story sharpens. Sixty-one per cent of respondents said their family finances were worse off than a year ago, up five points and a record high for that indicator. Only 17 per cent expected to be better off financially in 12 months — up two points, and tied for a record low. Just 14 per cent said it was a good time to buy major household items, against 48 per cent who said it was a bad time.

The divergence, and why it is not a rounding error

Set the two readings side by side. Expectations of further rate rises eased by eight percentage points in a month. Mortgage-holder sentiment fell to the weakest reading in the history of the series. Those move in opposite directions.

The straightforward reading is that fear of the next increase has started to come off the boil, while assessments of current and future personal finances have deteriorated to records. That makes sense against the backdrop. The Reserve Bank Board lifted the cash rate target by 25 basis points to 4.85 per cent on 3 November — six members in favour, three voting to hold at 4.60 per cent — and said that “a further tightening in financial conditions is warranted,” with inflation not expected to reach the top of the 2–3 per cent target range until late 2027. Most of the majors’ variable-rate increases took effect on 13 November, with Macquarie Bank’s scheduled for 19 November, according to Broker Daily’s tracking of lender announcements.

So the increase has arrived and is now being absorbed. Forecasters are split on whether more is coming: Angala said ANZ thinks “the cash rate has likely peaked at 4.85%,” while noting risks remain tilted toward further tightening; Hassan has said he does not expect an increase in February. Neither of those is a reason for your client to feel better. The repayment is already higher, the household’s assessment of its own position is at a record low, and the next decision is no longer the dominant variable.

Why this changes the broker conversation

For most of 2026, the binding constraint in the broker channel was capacity. Assessment rates moved with product rates, expense benchmarks were revised, and a great deal of broker skill went into finding the lender whose policy let a workable file through. That is a capacity problem, and brokers are good at it.

What these two surveys describe is not a capacity problem. It is a willingness problem. A client who can borrow and will not is a different file from a client who wants to borrow and cannot — and no amount of lender-policy knowledge solves the first one.

The distinction is commercial, not philosophical. A capacity constraint shows up as declines, workarounds and re-submissions. A willingness constraint shows up as silence: appointments that do not convert to applications, pre-approvals that lapse unused, clients who say they will “wait and see.” Your pipeline report looks busy and your settlement report does not.

There is already evidence the second pattern is running. The Australian Bureau of Statistics reported on 11 November that the value of new housing loan commitments fell 15.5 per cent in the September quarter to $81.2 billion, with the number of commitments down 15.0 per cent to 111,878 and down 21.4 per cent over the year. Investor commitments did most of the damage, falling 32.3 per cent by value, while owner-occupier commitments fell 5.3 per cent.

Application-level data points the same way. Reporting on CBA’s first-quarter FY2026–27 trading update, released 11 November, The Adviser said applications including Bankwest were 16 per cent below the same quarter a year earlier, and cited Equifax data showing mortgage demand down 19.2 per cent annually in September — a sixth consecutive monthly decline — with first home buyer applications down 22.1 per cent. The same update showed home loans more than 90 days overdue rising seven basis points in the quarter to 0.80 per cent. CBA chief executive Matt Comyn said “higher inflation and interest rates continue to place uneven pressure on household incomes and business activity.”

Demand is falling faster than capacity is tightening. That is the shape of a confidence problem.

The fixed-rate request that is really a cashflow request

Here is where the divergence becomes practical. When 72 per cent of consumers expect rates to rise, a predictable share of them will walk in asking to fix. When a record 61 per cent say they are already worse off than a year ago, some of those same clients are not asking for rate certainty at all — they are asking for a lower repayment, and “fix it” is the only lever they know the name of.

Those are different requests and they have different answers. ASIC’s Regulatory Guide 273, which sets out the regulator’s guidance on the mortgage broker best interests duty, is useful on exactly this point. RG 273.74 says that some consumers’ circumstances mean they may derive greater benefit from particular features than from a lower-cost product, and that ASIC does not expect a broker to comprehensively assess the separate value of each feature. RG 273.75 adds that where a product is recommended based on one of those features, “you should be able to make an overall assessment that the non-cost consideration has a realistic possibility of offering that individual consumer greater value.”

RG 273.76 then names the other side of it. Circumstances may show that a feature is irrelevant or detrimental to a particular consumer — and ASIC’s own first example is that “a fixed rate loan with a substantial break fee could be detrimental to a consumer who wants flexibility to refinance.”

Read that against a client whose finances are deteriorating. Rate certainty may be genuinely valuable to them. Or the realistic possibility over the next 24 months may be that they need to restructure, sell, consolidate or refinance — in which case a break fee is a cost imposed on the outcome they are most likely to need. The question is not whether fixing is good or bad. It is which of those two clients is sitting in front of you, and whether you asked.

This is general information, not advice on your obligations. How RG 273 applies to a particular file is a matter for your licensee’s process and, where you need it, your own compliance or legal adviser.

What belongs on the file when fear drives the decision

The record-keeping paragraphs of RG 273 are the ones that matter in a market like this, and they are not the ones most brokers quote. RG 273.169 says taking notes and keeping records contemporaneously “may help you to accurately capture your thinking and reasoning at each relevant point in time,” and that drafting notes only at the end of the process “may not be as effective.” RG 273.170 suggests a concise narrative summary connecting those records, which “should be evidence based and supported by contemporaneous records.”

Then the pair that is genuinely useful when a client’s stated preference is driven by sentiment. RG 273.171 says it is unlikely you will need to give reasons why you did not consider or recommend every alternative product on the market. RG 273.172 says there may be situations where recording why you did not recommend a certain product or type of product will help demonstrate compliance. ASIC’s Example 18 in RG 273 illustrates it with a consumer whose savings plans made an offset account a poor fit: the broker explains why, presents options without that feature, and takes thorough contemporaneous notes including the reasons for not considering those products.

Applied to a November 2026 file, that is a short list. If a client asked to fix and you recommended a fixed product, the file should show what non-cost benefit you assessed as having a realistic possibility of greater value for them. If a client asked to fix and you did not recommend it, the file should show why that type of product was not in their interests — break costs against a foreseeable need for flexibility is a legitimate, recordable reason. Either way, the reasoning belongs on the file at the time, not reconstructed later.

What to review this week

  1. Separate your stalled files by cause. Go through everything that has not progressed in 60 days and mark each one “cannot” or “will not”. The first group is a policy and lender problem. The second group is a confidence problem, and the two need different follow-up.
  2. Re-read your unconverted appointments from October. If the reason recorded is “waiting to see what rates do”, that reason has partly expired — the increase has landed and expectations of further rises have eased. That is a legitimate reason to make contact.
  3. Audit your fixed-rate conversations. For every fixed recommendation in the last quarter, check the file answers two questions: what did the client say they valued, and what did you assess as the realistic benefit to them. If the file only records the client’s request, the reasoning is missing.
  4. Check your pre-approval expiry list against the 13 November pass-through. Clients holding a pre-approval priced before the majors’ increases took effect are working from a number that has moved.
  5. Look at your own revenue mix, not just your volume. If appointments are holding and applications are falling, the problem is conversion, and the fix is in the conversation rather than the lead source.
  6. Prepare for the hardship question. With arrears rising at the largest lender in the market, more of your existing book will raise repayment difficulty with you before they raise it with their lender. Know your referral path to each lender’s hardship team and record what you told the client.

What to watch next

Three things over the next few weeks. The RBA’s December meeting, where both Westpac and ANZ expect no change but for different reasons. The next ANZ–Roy Morgan weekly readings, which will show whether 63.1 was a post-decision shock or a new level. And the December Westpac–Melbourne Institute survey, where the number to watch is not the headline index but the share expecting further rate rises. If that figure keeps falling while mortgage-holder sentiment stays at record lows, the willingness problem is structural rather than rate-driven — and the brokers who adjusted their conversation first will be the ones still converting.

The practical takeaway

A record low in mortgage-holder sentiment is not, by itself, something a broker can act on. The divergence inside it is. Rate-rise fear eased by eight percentage points in a month while the assessment households make of their own finances hit records in the other direction. That tells you which pitch has stopped working and which conversation has not started.

Brokers spent 2026 getting very good at solving capacity. The constraint in front of you now is a client who has the capacity and has lost the confidence — and that is a conversation about structure, cashflow and the next two years, not about the next cash rate decision.

Key takeaways

  • The Westpac–Melbourne Institute mortgage-holder sentiment sub-group fell 11.6% in November to 68.1, which Westpac describes as a record low on measures going back to 1994. The headline index fell 2.7% to 78.2.
  • In the same survey, the share of consumers expecting mortgage rates to rise over the next 12 months fell to 72%, from 80% in October and 64% in September.
  • ANZ–Roy Morgan Consumer Confidence fell 3.1 points to 63.1, with mortgage-holder confidence the weakest since that weekly series began in 2008. A record 61% said their family finances were worse off than a year ago, and 17% expected to be better off in a year — tied for a record low.
  • ABS data released 11 November showed the value of new housing loan commitments down 15.5% in the September quarter to $81.2bn, with investor commitments down 32.3% against 5.3% for owner-occupiers.
  • RG 273.74 to RG 273.76 deal with recommending a product on a non-cost feature, and ASIC’s own example notes that a fixed rate loan with a substantial break fee could be detrimental to a consumer who wants flexibility to refinance. RG 273.169 to RG 273.172 deal with contemporaneous records and recording why a type of product was not recommended. This is general information, not advice on your obligations.
  • The practical distinction for brokers is between a client who cannot borrow and a client who will not. The second group does not show up as declines — it shows up as unconverted appointments and lapsed pre-approvals.

Questions brokers are asking

Does a record low in mortgage-holder sentiment mean I have to change my pipeline process?

No regulatory obligation attaches to a sentiment reading. The practical implication is commercial: if your appointments are holding while your applications fall, the problem is conversion rather than lead flow, and segmenting stalled files into “cannot proceed” and “will not proceed” tells you which half needs a lender solution and which half needs a different conversation.

A client is asking to fix because they are worried about further rate rises. Is that enough to recommend a fixed product?

RG 273.75 says that where a product is recommended based on a non-cost feature, you should be able to make an overall assessment that the non-cost consideration has a realistic possibility of offering that individual consumer greater value. RG 273.76 notes the opposite case — that a fixed rate loan with a substantial break fee could be detrimental to a consumer who wants flexibility to refinance. The client’s request is an input, not the assessment. How this applies to a particular file is a matter for your licensee’s process and, where needed, your own compliance or legal adviser.

If I decide against recommending a fixed rate, does that need to be on the file?

RG 273.171 says it is unlikely you will need to give reasons why you did not consider or recommend every alternative product on the market. RG 273.172 says there may be situations where recording why you did not recommend a certain product or type of product will help demonstrate compliance, and ASIC’s Example 18 illustrates that with a broker who documents why products with a particular feature were not considered. Where a client asked for a product type and you recommended against it, that is the kind of reasoning worth recording at the time rather than later.

Have the November rate increases reached borrowers yet?

Broker Daily’s tracking of lender announcements put most of the majors’ variable-rate increases at 13 November, with Macquarie Bank’s scheduled for 19 November and AMP Bank’s from 9 November. The practical consequence is that pre-approvals and repayment quotes priced before those dates are working from a number that has since moved. Confirm current pricing with the lender before you revisit a quote.

What are forecasters saying about December and February?

ANZ economist Sophia Angala said ANZ thinks the cash rate has likely peaked at 4.85%, while noting risks remain tilted toward further tightening. Westpac’s Matthew Hassan has said he does not expect a cash rate increase in February. The RBA’s own 3 November statement said inflation is not expected to reach the top of the 2–3% target range until late 2027. Forecasts are not outcomes, and the decision belongs to the Board.

Breaking news for modern brokers

Market shifts, lender policy and compliance developments, written for the broker channel.

More at The Broker Times →
Interactive · Stalled file triage

Cannot Proceed, or Will Not Proceed?

Four questions on one stalled file. The tool sorts it into a capacity problem, a confidence problem or a product-conversation problem, and names the file note that goes with it.

Question 1 of 4

Has this client been declined, or come up short on a lender’s maximum, in the last 90 days?

Question 2 of 4

When you last spoke, what reason did the client give for not proceeding?

Question 3 of 4

Has the client asked about fixing, or asked how to get the repayment down?

Question 4 of 4

How long since you last made inquiries into this client’s circumstances?

0 of 4 answered

More market and compliance reporting for the broker channel at The Broker Times.

This tool is a general prompt for reviewing your own pipeline. It is not advice, it does not assess any obligation, and it produces no record. Your licensee’s process governs how the best interests duty and your responsible lending obligations apply to a particular file.

Fundwise: compare 19 business cashflow lenders side by side. Free for brokers, no credit card, 20 free AI credits.

Disclaimer: This article is for general information and professional development purposes only. It does not constitute legal, compliance, or financial advice. Brokers should consult their aggregator’s compliance team and, where required, seek independent legal advice regarding their obligations under the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 and ASIC’s responsible lending guidelines.