Listen to the Brief

Too Busy to Read? We’ve Got You.

Get this blog post’s insights delivered in a quick audio format — all in under 10 minutes.

Download Audio

This audio version covers: Compliance Deep Dive: A Step-by-Step Template for Documenting Best Interests Duty in Complex SMSF/Trust Scenarios

Compliance Deep Dive: A Step-by-Step Template for Documenting Best Interests Duty in Complex SMSF/Trust Scenarios

As a broker, you’ve faced it: the complex **SMSF** or discretionary trust scenario lands on your desk. Your client, often guided by their accountant, has a specific structure for asset protection or tax planning. You run the numbers, and the **lowest interest rate** on your screen is from a lender who wouldn't touch this file with a ten-foot pole.

The product that *can* be used—the one that actually accommodates the client's complex structure—is 50 basis points higher. This is the sharp end of the **Best Interests Duty (BID)**.

ASIC requires clear, defensible evidence justifying *why* that more expensive loan was in the customer’s best interests. In complex lending, a simple "lowest rate" comparison is not just unsuitable; it's a **compliance failure**. The key is **structured documentation** focusing on non-cost value. Use this robust, repeatable template to build your audit-proof defence.

The 5-Step Documentation Framework

Step 1: Define the Client's *True* Objectives (Beyond "The Loan")

Your file notes need to capture the *why* behind the complexity. This goes far beyond "client wishes to purchase an investment property." Your notes must connect the loan to the client's broader financial strategy, often dictated by their accountant or financial planner.

What to document:

  • **The Structure:** "Client is seeking finance via their Self-Managed Superannuation Fund (SMSF) with a limited recourse borrowing arrangement (LRBA)."
  • **The Professional Advice:** "We are acting on advice from the client's accountant (see attached email/letter) to preserve asset protection between their personal assets and their business operations."
  • **The Primary Objective:** "The client's primary objective is *not* rate, but (1) securing finance within their specific SMSF structure and (2) ensuring the loan covenants do not trigger personal guarantees that would break their asset protection strategy."

Step 2: Identify the "Can-Do" Lenders (The Policy Filter)

Before you even look at a rate, you must first filter the market by policy. Who can *actually* fund this deal? Sifting through 40+ lender policy documents manually is inefficient and ripe for error. Technology is now your core compliance tool here.

Actionable Tip: Automated Policy Search

Instead of "I checked with my top 5," leverage a specialist AI tool. Platforms like **BrokerBuddie.ai** offer an **SMSFBuddie** assistant, and **CreditPolicy.com.au** provides an AI Policy Engine to get an instant shortlist of "can-do" lenders based on complex criteria. **Document that a comprehensive market search was conducted.**

Step 3: Run the Comparative Analysis (Justifying Non-Cost Value)

Create your audit trail by formally detailing *why* the cheaper options were unsuitable and *why* the recommended product is the best fit, despite the cost. This documentation focuses purely on **non-cost value**.

Lender Interest Rate Suitability Justification for (Un)Suitability
Lender A (Cheapest) 6.15% **Not Suitable** Lender policy does not accommodate SMSF lending for commercial-use property.
Lender B (Mid-Rate) 6.35% **Not Suitable** Policy accommodates SMSF, but their required documentation includes personal guarantees, conflicting with the client's documented primary objective of asset protection.
Lender C (Recommended) 6.65% **Suitable & Recommended** **This product is in the client's best interest.** It accommodates the client's SMSF LRBA structure and does not require personal guarantees, upholding the client's primary objective.

Step 4: Write the Formal BID Justification Narrative

This is the plain-English summary that you can add to your compliance notes. It must be concise, direct, and conclusive.

Template Narrative:

In determining the best interests of the client, we have prioritised their stated primary objectives of asset protection and compatibility with their existing SMSF structure.

A review of the market identified that the lowest-cost products (e.g., Lender A at 6.15%) are not suitable as their policies do not support the client's required borrowing structure. Other products (e.g., Lender B at 6.35%) were also deemed unsuitable as their loan covenants would compromise the client's documented asset protection strategy.

The recommended product from Lender C, while at a higher interest rate of 6.65%, is in the client's best interests as it fully accommodates their complex SMSF structure and aligns with their long-term financial objectives. The non-cost value (structural compatibility and asset protection) was deemed to be the client's priority and the primary driver of this recommendation.

Step 5: Institutionalise It in Your Workflow

A great template is useless if your team doesn't use it consistently. The final step is to build this process directly into your brokerage's operations to ensure compliance safety.

Workflow Automation for Consistency:

  • **Required Steps:** Configure your CRM so a file marked "Complex (SMSF/Trust)" *cannot* be moved to "Submitted" until this **"Complex BID Justification"** note is formally completed.
  • **Compliance Checklists:** Use tools to manage document checklists, ensuring supporting evidence (like trust deeds or accountant letters) is gathered to back up your justification.

The Tech Toolkit for Steps 2 & 5

BrokerBuddie.ai

AI assistant platform trained on lender policies for specific scenarios, automating the heavy lifting in **Step 2**.

Relevant Features:

  • **SMSFBuddie:** Specialist AI trained on SMSF lending rules.
  • **ComplianceBuddie:** Helps manage document checklists.
Explore BrokerBuddie.ai

CreditPolicy.com.au

An all-in-one broker platform designed to manage policy, workflow, and compliance, crucial for **Step 5**.

Relevant Features:

  • **AI Policy Engine:** Find "can-do" lenders in natural language.
  • **Workflow Automation:** Build your BID justification template directly into your deal flow as a required step.
Explore CreditPolicy.com.au

The Takeaway: From Defence to Offence

This level of documentation isn't just about defending yourself in an audit; it's about **demonstrating your value**. It proves you are a strategic partner, not just a rate-chaser.

When you can confidently navigate complex structures, you build incredible trust with clients and, just as importantly, with the accountants and planners who refer them.

Adopt a structured template, leverage the AI tools that automate the heavy lifting, and turn your compliance obligations into your most powerful competitive advantage.